What Is an ICO? Initial Coin Offerings Explained

An initial coin offering (ICO) is a fundraising method in which a project sells newly created cryptocurrency tokens to the public in exchange for money, usually other cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin or ether, and sometimes fiat currency. The project uses the proceeds to build a blockchain network, application or service. Buyers receive tokens that may give access to that product, represent a claim on the project, or simply be expected to trade at a higher price later.

ICOs are often called the crypto equivalent of an initial public offering (IPO). The difference is that an ICO sells tokens, often before any product exists, and many offerings have taken place with little or no regulatory review. That gap explains both the ICO boom of 2017 to 2018 and the wave of fraud cases and enforcement actions that followed.

How an ICO works

An ICO follows a broadly similar sequence, though no single standard governs it:

1. Concept and team. Founders define a project, typically something built on a blockchain, and decide that selling tokens is how they will fund it.
2. Token design. The team decides how many tokens will exist, how they will be priced, what they will do inside the product, and how many the founders and early backers will keep.
3. White paper and website. The project publishes a white paper and a dedicated site explaining the offering.
4. Smart contract. Tokens are usually created by a smart contract on an existing blockchain. During the 2017 boom, most were issued on Ethereum under the ERC-20 token standard.
5. Presale and public sale. Some projects sell to early or large buyers first, often at a discount, then open a public sale for a fixed period. Buyers send funds to an address controlled by the project or its sale contract.
6. Distribution and listing. After the sale closes, tokens are distributed to buyers’ wallets. The project may then seek listings on exchanges so the tokens can trade.

The white paper

The white paper is the crypto version of a pitch book. It is a marketing and technical document, not a regulated prospectus, so its content and accuracy depend entirely on the issuer. A typical white paper covers:

• What the project does and the problem it claims to solve
• How the technology works and the development roadmap
• How much money the project aims to raise
• How many tokens exist and how many the founders will keep
• Which currencies the sale accepts
• How long the sale runs and how funds will be spent

A clear white paper states concrete goals and explains why the project needs its own token at all. Vague language, borrowed technical jargon and missing details on token allocation are reasons to stop reading. Some offerings have published white papers copied from other projects, so originality is worth checking too.

Token structures, with a hypothetical example

How supply and price are set determines what a buyer is actually paying for. ICOs generally use one of three structures. The figures below are a hypothetical example, not the terms of any real offering.

Static supply, static price. The project fixes both the number of tokens and the price. Suppose it offers 100 million tokens at $0.10 each. The maximum it can raise is 100,000,000 × $0.10 = $10 million. Once all tokens are sold, the sale ends.

Static supply, dynamic price. The number of tokens is fixed, but the price depends on how much money comes in. If the same 100 million tokens are offered and buyers contribute a total of $25 million, the effective price is $25,000,000 ÷ 100,000,000 = $0.25 per token. Each buyer receives tokens in proportion to their share of total contributions: someone who contributed $2,500 (0.01% of the total) gets 0.01% of the tokens, or 10,000 tokens. Buyers do not know their final price until the sale closes.

Dynamic supply, static price. The price is fixed, and the project creates as many tokens as the funds require. At $0.10 per token, a $6 million raise produces 60 million tokens; a $15 million raise produces 150 million. Here a buyer knows the price but not the final total supply, which affects how much of the network each token represents.

Founder allocation changes the math further. Continuing the first example, if the founders keep an additional 25 million tokens on top of the 100 million sold, total supply is 125 million and public buyers hold 80% of it. If those founder tokens can be sold immediately after listing, they can add heavy selling pressure. Many projects use vesting schedules that release founder and team tokens gradually, and the white paper should state whether such a schedule exists.

Caps, refunds and what happens after the sale

Many ICOs set a soft cap, the minimum amount the project needs to proceed, and a hard cap, the maximum it will accept. If the sale fails to reach the soft cap within the stated period, the offering may be declared unsuccessful and funds returned to contributors, depending on the sale terms. Whether refunds happen automatically through the smart contract or rely on the team’s promise is a material difference: code can enforce a refund, while a promise cannot.

If the funding target is met, the project keeps the money and spends it on development, salaries, marketing and other costs. ICO buyers usually have no board seats and no audit rights over that spending. Some projects hold raised funds in an escrow or multi-signature wallet, which requires several independent keys to move money. That arrangement makes it harder for one insider to disappear with the funds, although it does not guarantee the project will deliver.

How ICOs are regulated in the U.S.

Creating a cryptocurrency is not illegal in many jurisdictions. What brings regulation in is selling it to investors in a way that resembles a securities offering. Each country applies its own test; in the U.S., the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) applies the Howey Test.

The Howey Test

The test comes from the 1946 Supreme Court case SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., which involved sales of citrus grove plots with service contracts. An arrangement is an investment contract, and therefore a security, if it involves:

• An investment of money
• In a common enterprise
• With an expectation of profits
• Derived from the efforts of others

A token sale where buyers pay money, the funds are pooled to build a project, and buyers expect the token to rise in value because of the team’s work fits that pattern closely. Calling the token a “utility token” does not change the analysis; regulators look at the economic reality of the sale, not its label. The SEC treats an unregistered, non-exempt securities sale as an unregistered offering and can force compliance.

Registration exemptions

Some token sales that are securities can still be sold legally without full registration. One route is Rule 504 of Regulation D, which allows an issuer to offer and sell up to $10 million in securities in a 12-month period, provided it files a notice on Form D after its first sale. Form D filings are public and searchable in the SEC’s EDGAR database, so a buyer can check whether an issuer that claims an exemption actually filed. Other exemptions exist with different limits and investor restrictions.

Enforcement examples

• Munchee (2017). On Dec. 11, 2017, the SEC halted an ICO by Munchee, a California company with a food review app, which was raising money for a token that would be used to order food in the app. The SEC issued a cease-and-desist order treating the sale as an unregistered securities offering. It was the agency’s first action of this kind against an ICO.
• Telegram (2018 to 2020). Telegram raised $1.7 billion from investors in 2018 and 2019 for its planned token. The SEC filed an emergency action and obtained a temporary restraining order, arguing the sale was an unregistered offering. In March 2020, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York granted a preliminary injunction, and Telegram ultimately agreed to return $1.2 billion to investors and pay an $18.5 million civil penalty.

Regulators tend to act after money has been raised, so investors may wait a long time, and recover less than they paid, when an offering is stopped.

A short history of ICOs

Mastercoin, which held a token sale in 2013, is widely cited as the first ICO. The model gained credibility with Ethereum’s ICO in 2014, which raised about $18 million over 42 days by selling ether for bitcoin. Ethereum then became the platform that made later ICOs easy to run, because its smart contracts let anyone issue a token without writing a new blockchain.

Activity peaked in 2017 to 2018. During a one-month sale ending in March 2018, Dragon Coin raised about $320 million. Later in 2018, the company behind the EOS platform raised about $4 billion in a sale that lasted roughly a year, one of the largest token sales on record.

ICO activity declined sharply after that peak, partly because of legal ambiguity and regulatory attention, and partly because many funded projects never delivered. Fundraising shifted toward the formats below and toward token launches tied to DeFi protocols.

ICO vs. IPO

ICO vs. IEO, IDO and STO

Several related terms describe variations on the token sale:

• Initial exchange offering (IEO): A centralized exchange runs the token sale on behalf of the project. Buyers purchase through their exchange accounts, and the exchange typically lists the token afterward. The exchange’s screening adds a layer of review, but its standards are its own, not a regulator’s.
• Initial DEX offering (IDO): The sale takes place on a decentralized exchange or launchpad, with tokens and liquidity managed by smart contracts.
• Security token offering (STO): The token is openly treated as a security from the start and sold under securities law, through registration or an exemption.
• Airdrop: Tokens are distributed free, often to existing users of a network, rather than sold. No money is raised from recipients.

Risks of ICOs

Fraud. Because launching an ICO requires little more than a website, a white paper and a smart contract, it is one of the easiest fundraising formats to fake. Scammers have used fabricated teams, fake registration documents, forged approval letters and impersonation emails.

No delivery. A legitimate team can still fail. Funds raised for a product that never ships are usually spent, and token holders generally have no legal claim to whatever money remains.

Weak rights. Unless the offering terms grant them, tokens carry no ownership, dividends or votes. Your position depends on the token’s market price.

Liquidity and price risk. A token may never be listed on an exchange, leaving buyers unable to sell. If it is listed, prices of new tokens can swing sharply, especially when founder or presale allocations unlock.

Regulatory risk. An offering later found to be an unregistered securities sale may be halted, and exchanges may delist its token.

Operational risk. Sending funds to a wrong or spoofed address cannot be reversed. Some ICOs accept only specific cryptocurrencies, so buyers may first need to acquire those coins, adding exchange fees and price exposure before the sale begins.

Hype and celebrity endorsements

ICOs often build momentum through online communities and paid promotion. The SEC has warned that celebrities and other promoters who endorse securities offerings, including ICOs, must disclose any compensation they receive; failing to do so is illegal under U.S. securities law.

Centra Tech illustrates the problem. Boxing champion Floyd Mayweather Jr. and music producer DJ Khaled promoted the Centra Tech ICO, which raised about $30 million in late 2017. Both later settled SEC charges over undisclosed promotional payments, and three Centra Tech founders pleaded guilty to fraud charges. Actor Steven Seagal was also charged by the SEC for promoting a digital asset offering without disclosing his compensation.

How to evaluate an ICO

1. Verify the team. Confirm the named founders are real people with a checkable history in software, crypto or the project’s industry. Anonymous teams or stock photos are warning signs.
2. Read the white paper critically. Apply the tests above, and search distinctive passages to see whether the text was copied.
3. Check token allocation and vesting. Find out what share goes to founders, advisers and presale buyers, and when those tokens unlock.
4. Look at the code. Many legitimate projects publish their code on GitHub and commission independent smart contract audits. An active development history says more than marketing activity.
5. Confirm the legal status. For U.S. offerings that claim an exemption, search EDGAR for a Form D.
6. Check how funds are held. Look for escrow or multi-signature arrangements and automatic refund conditions.
7. Read the terms and conditions. They define what you are buying, which countries can participate and what happens if the sale fails.
8. Treat promotion skeptically. Undisclosed paid endorsements, guaranteed returns and countdown pressure to buy are classic signs of a scam.

Listing sites and data aggregators help you find offerings and their code repositories and social channels, but they generally do not vet the projects they list. A later listing on an established exchange means the token passed that exchange’s own screening. That is why some investors wait for a token to trade on reputable crypto exchanges rather than buy in the sale itself.

BitcoinBTC$64,908EthereumETH$1,817SolanaSOL$71.49

Editorial credits