What Are Tariffs and Trade Barriers? Advantages and Drawbacks

Search Fintrev

Search our guides, reviews and glossary.

What Are Tariffs and Trade Barriers?

A tariff is a duty levied on goods when they cross into a country’s customs territory. It raises the cost of the imported product relative to a comparable domestic product. Tariffs are one tool of protectionism, the policy of shielding domestic producers from foreign competition.

Trade barriers are the broader category. They include tariffs and also non-tariff barriers: import quotas, import licenses, voluntary export restraints, local content requirements, product standards, and subsidies paid to domestic producers. Each works in one of two ways. It either makes foreign goods more expensive in the domestic market or limits how many of them can enter.

Tariffs can, in principle, apply to exports too (an export duty), but in modern usage “tariff” almost always means an import tax. When country A puts a tariff on goods from country B, the tax is charged in country A, on goods arriving from B. Country B’s government does not pay it.

How Tariffs and Trade Barriers Work

Who Collects a Tariff?

Tariffs are paid to the customs authority of the country that imposes them. In the United States, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) assesses and collects duties at the border. In the United Kingdom, HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) collects them.

The legal payer is the importer of record, the domestic business or individual bringing the goods in. Economically, an importer facing a new duty can raise its selling price, accept a thinner margin, or push the foreign supplier to cut its price, and the burden is split among these parties in proportions that vary by product and market. The exporting country’s treasury never receives a bill.

Tariffs also reach goods that are not obviously “foreign.” A domestic manufacturer that uses imported steel, chips or components pays more for those inputs, and it can pass that higher cost on in the price of its finished product.

Common Types of Tariffs

Specific tariffs charge a fixed amount per unit of the good. A government might set a duty of $15 per pair of imported shoes and $300 per imported computer. The duty is the same whether the shoes are cheap or expensive, so a specific tariff weighs more heavily on low-priced goods. It also loses force over time when prices rise, because the fixed amount becomes a smaller share of the product’s value.

Ad valorem tariffs charge a percentage of the good’s value. The term is Latin for “according to value.” A 15% ad valorem tariff on an imported car with a customs value of $40,000 produces a duty of $6,000, so the importer’s landed cost rises to $46,000 before shipping, dealer markup and sales tax. The duty is calculated on the customs value of the goods, not on the final retail price.

Compound tariffs combine the two, for example a per-unit charge plus a percentage of value.

Tariff-rate quotas apply a low tariff rate to imports up to a set quantity and a higher rate to anything above it. They blend a tariff with a quota and are common for agricultural goods.

Several duties are defined by the reason they are imposed rather than how they are calculated:

• Anti-dumping duties target goods sold abroad below their normal value, often below the price charged in the exporter’s home market.
• Countervailing duties offset subsidies a foreign government gives its exporters.
• Safeguard measures are temporary tariffs or quotas a country may impose when a sudden surge of imports causes or threatens serious injury to a domestic industry, even if no unfair practice is involved.

Non-Tariff Barriers to Trade

Import licenses. The government grants certain businesses the right to import a given product. If only a few companies hold licenses to import cheese, competition among importers is limited and prices tend to rise.

Import quotas. A quota caps the quantity or value of a good that may be imported in a period, such as a limit on tons of citrus fruit per year. Quotas are often administered through licenses. Unlike a tariff, a quota sets the volume of imports directly, and the domestic price adjusts to whatever level clears the market with that limited supply. The government collects no revenue from a quota unless it sells the licenses; otherwise the price markup goes to whoever holds the right to import.

Voluntary export restraints (VERs). The exporting country limits its own shipments, usually at the importing country’s request. In a hypothetical case, Brazil restricts sugar exports to Canada at Canada’s request, and Canada restricts coal exports to Brazil, raising both prices in the receiving markets while protecting each domestic industry. VERs are “voluntary” only in a formal sense, since they are typically agreed to avoid harsher measures.

Local content requirements. Instead of capping imports, the government requires that a share of a product be made domestically. The rule can be set by physical components (25% of a computer’s parts must be locally produced) or by value (15% of the computer’s value must come from domestic components).

Standards and regulations. Health, safety, labeling and technical standards can act as barriers when foreign producers find them costly to meet. Many standards have legitimate purposes, which is why they are among the most disputed barriers in trade negotiations.

Subsidies. Payments or tax breaks to domestic producers do not block imports directly. They lower domestic producers’ costs so they can undercut foreign competitors at home or abroad.

Interpreting Tariffs and Trade Barriers

The standard way to read a tariff is a domestic supply (DS) and domestic demand (DD) diagram, showing how much local buyers want and local producers make at each price. In an open economy, the price is set by the world price, labeled P*.

At the world price, domestic consumers buy more than domestic producers make. The gap between the two quantities is filled by imports. When a tariff is added, the domestic price rises to P’ (the world price plus the tariff, in a simple model). At the higher price:

• domestic producers expand output, moving along the supply curve;
• consumers buy less, moving back along the demand curve;
• imports, the gap between the two, shrink.

The result is less trade, more domestic production and higher prices for consumers. Removing the tariff reverses each movement: the price falls back to P*, domestic production contracts, consumption rises and imports expand.

This basic model assumes a “small” country, one whose purchases are too minor to change the world price. A large importer can push the world price down when its tariff reduces demand, shifting part of the burden onto foreign suppliers.

Why Are Tariffs and Trade Barriers Important?

Trade barriers matter because they change who gains and who loses from international trade. Governments justify them on several grounds.

Protecting Domestic Employment

Competition from cheaper imports can push domestic firms to cut jobs or move production abroad. Concentrated job losses are politically visible, so tariff decisions are often highly politicized. Domestic industries frequently argue that foreign rivals benefit from low wages, weaker labor protections or lighter regulation.

Economists counter with the principle of comparative advantage: countries gain by specializing in what they produce at the lowest opportunity cost and trading for the rest. Protecting an industry that has lost its comparative advantage keeps labor and capital in lower-value uses.

Protecting Consumers

A government may restrict or tax imports it believes could harm its population. A country might limit imported beef over concerns about animal disease, or block products that fail its safety standards.

Infant Industries

The infant industry argument holds that a new domestic industry needs temporary protection until it is large and efficient enough to compete. Many developing countries applied it through import substitution industrialization (ISI), taxing imports of manufactured goods so local factories could capture the home market and the economy could shift from exporting raw commodities to producing finished goods and creating industrial jobs. The criticism is that protection can become permanent. An industry that never faces competition may keep producing lower-quality goods at higher cost, and sustaining it can drag on overall growth.

National Security

Countries protect industries they consider strategically vital, especially defense and the supply chains behind it. Industrialized economies, including the United States and Western European nations, extend significant protection to defense-related producers even though they otherwise favor open trade.

Retaliation

A country may raise tariffs on a trading partner it believes is breaking the rules. A hypothetical example: if France concluded that U.S. producers were improperly labeling domestic sparkling wine as “Champagne,” it could impose tariffs on selected U.S. goods until the issue was addressed. Retaliatory tariffs can also pressure a partner over foreign policy disputes or answer its own trade barriers with “reciprocal” duties.

Government Revenue

Tariffs raise money. For governments with limited ability to collect income or consumption taxes, customs duties can be a meaningful share of revenue, which is one reason tariff levels differ so much between richer and poorer economies.

Example of Tariffs and Trade Barriers

The following hypothetical example shows the mechanics of the DS/DD diagram with illustrative figures, not a real market.

Assume a small country imports widgets at a world price of $10. Domestic demand is Qd = 120 − 4P and domestic supply is Qs = 4P − 20 (quantities in thousands of units). The government imposes a specific tariff of $2 per widget, and the full tariff passes through to the domestic price.

Now measure who gains and loses (in thousands of dollars):

• Consumers lose the area under the demand curve between $10 and $12: $2 × (80 + 72) ÷ 2 = 152.
• Domestic producers gain the area above the supply curve between $10 and $12: $2 × (20 + 28) ÷ 2 = 48.
• The government collects $2 × 44 = 88 in tariff revenue.
• The remainder, 152 − 48 − 88 = 16, is the deadweight loss: value lost to the economy that no one receives.

The deadweight loss comes from two triangles. The production triangle (8) reflects domestic firms making 8,000 extra widgets at a higher cost than the world price. The consumption triangle (8) reflects 8,000 widgets that consumers would have valued above $10 but no longer buy at $12.

This is the core reason most economists view tariffs as costly: the gains to producers and the treasury are smaller than the loss to consumers. A quota that limited imports to 44,000 units would produce the same $12 price and the same deadweight loss, but the 88 would go to quota holders instead of the government, unless the licenses were auctioned.

Limitations of Tariffs and Trade Barriers

Benefits are concentrated, costs are spread. Protected producers and their workers see clear gains. Consumers and downstream businesses each pay a little more, which is harder to see but larger in total.

Input costs spread through the economy. A tariff on steel raises costs for automakers, appliance makers and builders that use steel. Jobs protected in the steel industry can be offset by higher costs, lower sales or lost competitiveness in industries that buy steel.

Short-run gains can fade. In the short run, protected firms may earn higher profits and the government collects more duties, while higher prices reduce how much households and businesses buy. Over time, sheltered firms can become less efficient for lack of competition, and buyers may switch to substitutes, eroding the profits the tariff was meant to protect.

Retaliation and trade wars. A tariff invites a response, and when trading partners retaliate, the original country’s exporters lose access to foreign markets. The U.S. Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 raised duties on thousands of goods and was followed by retaliation from other countries as global trade contracted sharply during the Great Depression. The episode is widely cited as a lesson in the costs of escalating protection.

Effect on prices and inflation. Whether a tariff shows up as broad inflation depends on how many goods are covered and how much of the cost passes through. A tariff on a narrow set of products changes relative prices. A wide-ranging tariff can lift the overall price level measured by the Consumer Price Index. Economists distinguish this one-time increase in the price level from ongoing inflation, which requires prices to keep rising year after year.

Limits under trade agreements. The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), signed in 1947, and the World Trade Organization (WTO), established in 1995, reduced tariffs through successive negotiating rounds. WTO members commit to bound tariff rates, ceilings they agree not to exceed, and generally must apply the same rates to all members (most-favored-nation treatment), with exceptions for free trade agreements and preferences for developing countries. These commitments make large tariff increases harder to justify, which has pushed governments toward non-tariff barriers such as quotas, standards and export restraints.

Safeguards vs. Ordinary Tariffs

An ordinary tariff is a standing duty set in a country’s tariff schedule. A safeguard is a temporary emergency tariff or quota used when imports surge and seriously injure a domestic industry. Under WTO rules it is limited in duration, meant to apply without singling out particular countries, and can entitle affected exporters to compensation. Anti-dumping and countervailing duties instead respond to specific unfair practices (below-value pricing or foreign subsidies) and require an investigation finding that the practice exists and is causing injury.

FAQs

Economic drawbacks of lowering trade barriers

Lowering barriers usually helps consumers and exporters, but adjustment has costs. Protected industries may shrink, with job losses concentrated in particular regions and occupations, and workers may need time and retraining to move into growing sectors. Governments that depend on customs duties must replace that revenue with other taxes, young industries may not survive open competition, and a country can become more dependent on foreign suppliers for strategic goods.

Does a developing country have more leniency when implementing tariffs above the binding tariff rate?

Not automatically. A bound rate is a ceiling for every WTO member, and raising an applied tariff above it without following WTO procedures breaches that commitment. In practice, many developing countries bound their rates well above the rates they apply, so they can raise applied tariffs up to the ceiling without any breach. GATT Article XVIII also lets developing countries renegotiate or temporarily depart from concessions to establish a particular industry or address balance-of-payments problems, subject to consultation and, in some cases, compensation. Safeguard rules apply to all members, with some special treatment for developing countries.

The Bottom Line

Trade barriers matter to consumers, importers and businesses that rely on imported inputs, since they raise domestic prices and shift who gains from trade. Protected producers and the government collecting duties benefit, but in the standard model their gains are smaller than the loss to consumers. Retaliation, higher input costs and fading efficiency can erode the protection a tariff was meant to provide.