Difference Between Mutual Funds and Hedge Funds: A Clear Comparison

Search Fintrev

Search our guides, reviews and glossary.

Mutual funds and hedge funds differ mainly in access and rules. Both pool investors’ money and hand it to a manager who buys securities according to a strategy. A mutual fund is a public product. It is registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), open to almost anyone and sold with a prospectus, and an open-end fund lets you redeem shares at that day’s net asset value. A hedge fund is a private product. It is generally limited to accredited investors, governed by private offering documents rather than a public prospectus, free to use leverage, short selling and derivatives, and able to restrict when you can take money out. Hedge funds also tend to charge more, often through a performance fee that mutual funds do not use in the same way.

Access, disclosure and structure

• Who can buy: Mutual funds are sold to the general public, with minimums that can start around $250 to $3,000. Hedge funds are offered privately, mainly to accredited investors, with minimums that may run from $100,000 to $1 million or more.
• Disclosure: A mutual fund publishes a prospectus and reports its holdings and performance publicly. A hedge fund is not required to publish a prospectus. It discloses its terms only to its own investors, through a private placement memorandum, a limited partnership or operating agreement, and subscription documents, which together set out the strategy, fees and redemption rights.
• Legal structure: Mutual funds are investment companies with boards of directors. Hedge funds are often organized as limited partnerships, with the manager acting as general partner and investors as limited partners.

How mutual funds work

Mutual funds come in two styles: passive funds, which track an index at low cost, and active funds, where a professional manager picks securities to try to beat a benchmark. An index fund is simply a mutual fund (or ETF) run passively, so it sits on the mutual fund side of this comparison.

Regulation rests on two federal laws. The Securities Act of 1933 requires a prospectus that explains the fund’s objectives, risks and costs. The Investment Company Act of 1940 governs how the fund is structured and operated, including rules on custody, governance and limits on borrowing. Those limits are a large part of why a typical mutual fund looks conservative next to a hedge fund: the law, not just the manager’s preference, constrains how much leverage it can carry.

Most people mean open-end funds when they say “mutual fund.” You buy or sell shares directly with the fund at the net asset value (NAV) calculated after the market closes, and the fund creates or retires shares as money comes in and goes out. Open-end funds often offer several share classes, each with a different mix of ongoing fees and sales loads.

How hedge funds work

A hedge fund uses the same pooled structure, but it is offered privately, and that single fact drives nearly every other difference. Because it does not sell to the public, it can design its own investment terms, fee arrangements and withdrawal rules.

Who can invest

Hedge funds typically raise money under Regulation D of the Securities Act of 1933, mainly from accredited investors. Rule 506(b) also allows up to 35 non-accredited investors if the fund does not use general solicitation. For an individual, accredited status generally means net worth above $1 million (excluding the primary residence) or income above $200,000 a year ($300,000 jointly with a spouse) in each of the last two years with the same expected this year. These investors are presumed able to evaluate complex risks and absorb losses, so they give up some of the protections of registered funds in exchange for access.

To avoid registering as investment companies, hedge funds commonly rely on the exemptions in Sections 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the 1940 Act. The first caps the number of investors; the second allows more investors but limits them to “qualified purchasers,” a higher wealth threshold than accredited status.

Strategy and leverage

Without the 1940 Act’s constraints, hedge funds can borrow to amplify positions, sell short, trade options and futures, concentrate in a few ideas, or trade across global markets and asset classes. Many try to produce returns regardless of whether markets are rising or falling, which is part of the “hedge” in the name, though plenty of hedge funds take directional bets rather than hedging them away. Strategies range from long/short equity to global macro, event-driven and relative value.

Liquidity: when you can get your money back

Redemption terms may be the difference that matters most in practice. An open-end mutual fund investor can redeem on any business day and receive that day’s NAV.

Hedge fund liquidity is set in the fund’s documents. Some funds allow redemptions weekly or monthly; others only quarterly or once a year, often with an advance notice period. Many impose a lock-up, an initial stretch during which you cannot withdraw at all. Funds may also use gates that limit how much can leave in one period, and some suspend redemptions entirely. During the 2008 financial crisis, several hedge funds halted withdrawals to avoid being forced to sell assets at distressed prices, which protected remaining investors but trapped those who wanted out. Your actual redemption rights are whatever the offering memorandum says.

Fees and what they do to returns

Mutual fund operating expenses range from about 0.05% for some index funds to 5% or more when you include higher-cost active funds and sales loads. The expense ratio is deducted from fund assets, so it lowers your return whether the fund gains or loses.

Hedge funds were long associated with “two and twenty”: a 2% annual management fee on assets plus a 20% performance fee on profits. Average hedge fund fees have come down from those levels, but the two-part structure remains common. Many funds pair the incentive fee with a high-water mark, meaning the manager earns it only on gains above the fund’s previous peak value, and some add a hurdle rate the fund must clear first.

Example: the same gross return, two fee structures

This is a hypothetical example, not the terms of any real fund. Assume you invest $100,000 for one year, each fund earns a 10% gross return before fees, fees are calculated on the starting balance, the hedge fund’s 20% incentive fee applies to the gain remaining after the management fee, and there is no hurdle.

• Mutual fund with a 0.50% expense ratio: $10,000 gain minus $500 in expenses leaves $9,500, a 9.5% net return.
• Hedge fund at 2 and 20: $10,000 gain minus the $2,000 management fee leaves $8,000. The 20% performance fee on that is $1,600. Your net gain is $6,400, a 6.4% net return.

Under these assumptions, the hedge fund would need a gross return of about 13.9% to match the mutual fund’s 9.5% net: (13.875% minus 2%) × 0.8 = 9.5%. The fee gap is the hurdle the manager’s skill has to clear before the investor benefits. In a losing year, the hedge fund’s performance fee falls away, but the management fee is still charged.

Comparing performance

Mutual fund returns are public, standardized and easy to compare against a benchmark. Hedge fund results are not publicly reported in the same way, so comparisons usually rely on hedge fund indexes built from returns that participating funds report. These indexes are often set against the S&P 500 and against stock and bond mutual fund categories.

Three cautions apply. Hedge fund index figures are generally net of fees. A strategy that aims for lower volatility or gains in down markets may trail stocks in a strong bull market and still be doing what it promised. And individual hedge funds within any category can produce results far apart from one another, so an index average tells you little about a specific fund.

Exceptions that blur the line

The public/private split holds as a rule, but several products sit between the two categories.

• Liquid alternative funds: Some registered mutual funds and ETFs run hedge-fund-style strategies such as long/short equity or managed futures. They offer daily liquidity and public disclosure but must stay within 1940 Act limits on leverage and illiquid holdings, so they cannot replicate every hedge fund approach.
• ETFs: Exchange-traded funds are registered funds that trade on an exchange during the day. On regulation and access they belong with mutual funds.
• Closed-end funds: These issue a fixed number of shares that trade on an exchange at a price that can sit above or below NAV, so you exit by selling to another investor rather than redeeming with the fund. That limits redemptions like a hedge fund, but closed-end funds are publicly registered. A hedge fund is not a closed-end fund in the legal sense, even if its withdrawals are restricted.
• Private equity funds: These are also private and limited to wealthy or institutional investors, but they typically buy whole companies or private stakes and lock capital up for years, whereas hedge funds mainly trade liquid securities.
• Asset managers: Some firms run both registered funds and private hedge funds. The firm’s name does not tell you which product you own; the fund’s offering documents do.

Which one fits

For most investors the choice is made by eligibility. If you are not accredited, mutual funds, index funds and ETFs are the realistic options, and they offer diversification, daily liquidity and published costs. If you qualify for hedge funds, the question is whether a particular manager’s strategy adds something your portfolio lacks, such as returns that do not move with stocks, and whether that justifies higher fees and less access to your money.

FAQs

The Bottom Line

Eligibility settles the question for most investors, since non-accredited buyers are limited to mutual funds, index funds and ETFs with daily liquidity and published costs. Investors who qualify for hedge funds should judge whether a specific manager adds something their portfolio lacks, such as returns that do not track stocks. That benefit has to justify higher fees and redemption terms set by the offering documents.