Comprehensive Guide to Private and Public Equity Differences

Search Fintrev

Search our guides, reviews and glossary.

Public equity is ownership in companies whose shares trade on a stock exchange, where anyone with a brokerage account can buy or sell them. Private equity is ownership in companies whose shares do not trade on an exchange. It is usually offered to accredited investors and institutions through private placements or private equity funds. Both give you a claim on a company’s ownership and its potential returns. They differ in who can invest, how easily you can exit, how much the company must disclose, and how investors get paid.

What public equity means

Public equities are shares of companies registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and listed on a public exchange such as the New York Stock Exchange or Nasdaq. Because the shares trade continuously during market hours, investors can usually enter or exit a position on any trading day at a market price visible to everyone.

Most people already hold public equity, often without buying a single stock, through mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), 401(k) plans and IRAs. Broad indexes such as the S&P 500, the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the Nasdaq Composite track large groups of public companies and serve as market benchmarks.

The trade-off for this access is regulation. Public companies must publish audited financial statements, file regular reports, and disclose material events. Investors therefore get a steady flow of information they can use for fundamental analysis, and management operates under constant scrutiny from shareholders, analysts and regulators.

What private equity means

Private equity covers ownership stakes in companies that are not listed on an exchange. Most companies begin as private businesses funded by founders, friends and family, angel investors or venture capital. Some stay private; others raise larger rounds from private equity investors before going public. Public companies can also be taken private when owners decide the benefits of being private outweigh those of a listing.

Investors reach private equity in two main ways:

1. Direct private placements, where a company sells shares to a limited group of investors without a public registration.
2. Private equity funds, which pool capital from investors and buy stakes in, or full control of, private companies. These funds are commonly organized as limited partnerships. A general partner manages the fund, and limited partners supply most of the capital. Investors commit an amount up front, and the manager calls that capital over time as it finds deals.

Because private offerings are exempt from many registration requirements, they are generally restricted to more sophisticated buyers. In the U.S., those buyers are usually accredited investors, a category defined in Regulation D. For individuals, the standard tests include a net worth above $1 million (excluding the value of a primary residence), or income above $200,000 in each of the past two years ($300,000 jointly with a spouse or partner) with the expectation of the same in the current year. Institutions such as banks, pension funds and endowments can also qualify.

Instead of a prospectus, a private offering is described in a private placement memorandum (PPM), which sets out the investment’s structure, risks, investor requirements and distribution expectations. It is not reviewed and registered the way a prospectus is.

Core differences at a glance

How investors get paid

With public equity, your return is the change in the share price plus any dividends. You decide when to sell. If a stock rises 20% and you want the gain, you can place a sell order and typically receive cash within the standard settlement period.

With private equity, investors are generally paid through distributions rather than by selling shares on a market. A fund or company returns cash as it earns income, refinances, or sells holdings, and the timing follows the terms in the PPM or partnership agreement, not the investor’s preference. Many private equity funds show what is often called a J-curve: in the early years, fees and capital calls make reported returns negative, and distributions pick up later as investments are sold.

Consider a hypothetical example. An investor puts $100,000 into an S&P 500 index fund and commits another $100,000 to a private equity fund. The index fund money is invested immediately and can be withdrawn on any trading day. The private commitment may be drawn in pieces over several years, and most of the cash may come back only when the fund sells its companies near the end of its life. The investor must keep enough cash on hand to meet each capital call, even if public markets are falling.

Regulation and disclosure

Public companies operate under dense federal rules. The Securities Act of 1933 governs how securities are first offered to the public. The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 created the SEC and requires ongoing reports, including annual 10-K and quarterly 10-Q filings.

The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, passed after the accounting scandals at Enron, Tyco and WorldCom, holds senior executives personally responsible for the accuracy of financial statements and requires detailed reporting on internal controls over financial reporting. Compliance takes significant time and money, especially for smaller companies.

Private companies and private equity funds are largely outside these requirements. Investors get less standardized information and less regulatory protection, which is why private offerings are limited to buyers presumed able to evaluate and absorb the risk. Management gets a lighter reporting burden and more discretion. It answers to a smaller group of investors, makes distribution decisions on its own schedule, and plans around commitments solicited over time instead of quarterly earnings expectations.

Moving between private and public

Going public through an IPO

Many private equity deals assume the company will one day go public, giving early investors a way to sell. Private startups valued at $1 billion or more, called “unicorns,” are often discussed as IPO candidates.

An IPO is led by one or more investment banks acting as underwriters. They help value the company, gauge investor demand, market the offering, set the price, handle much of the documentation and SEC filings, and distribute shares before trading begins. Underwriters often take a position in the offering themselves, and investment banks play a similar role in large private placements.

Going private through a buyout

The reverse path is a take-private transaction, often structured as a leveraged buyout, where borrowed money funds much of the purchase. Dell is the classic example. In 2013, after about 25 years as a public company, founder and CEO Michael Dell partnered with Silver Lake Partners and used borrowed funds to take the company private. Dell no longer had to satisfy public shareholders seeking dividends or decide on buybacks that would move its share price, and it could restructure away from quarterly public scrutiny.

Comparing returns and risk

Private equity is associated with higher potential returns, but it also carries higher risk, longer time horizons and limited liquidity. Comparing the two is harder than it looks.

Public equity returns are easy to track against published indexes such as the S&P 500, the Dow or the Nasdaq Composite at any time. Private equity returns come from industry reports, usually monthly or quarterly, by consulting firms, fund managers and trade publications. Those figures rest on periodic valuations rather than market prices, so they can look smoother than public returns even when the underlying businesses are just as volatile.

The risks also take different forms:

• Liquidity risk. Public shares can usually be sold quickly. Private stakes may be impossible to sell before the fund or company returns capital, and any secondary sale is negotiated privately and may come at a discount.
• Information risk. Public investors get standardized, audited disclosures. Private investors rely on the PPM and on what the manager reports.
• Concentration and leverage. Buyout funds often own a small number of companies and use debt to finance deals, which increases both gains and losses.
• Market risk. Public shares respond immediately to news, interest rates and swings between bull and bear markets. That volatility is visible every day, while private holdings register it only when they are revalued.

Which fits which investor

For most individual investors, public equity is the practical route to stock ownership. It requires no accreditation, can be bought in small amounts, is held in retirement accounts, and can be sold when cash is needed. Mandatory disclosure also makes it easier to research, and the tools of stock analysis are built around that public information.

Private equity suits investors who meet the accreditation thresholds, can lock up capital for years, can meet capital calls, and are willing to rely on a manager’s judgment and reporting in exchange for access to companies that are not listed. Institutions such as pension funds and endowments use it as one part of a broader portfolio, not as a replacement for public holdings.

Non-accredited investors usually cannot buy private placements directly. Some public vehicles, such as listed shares of asset managers that run private equity funds, give indirect exposure. They still trade like public equity and carry public-market price swings, so they are not the same as owning a private fund stake.

The Bottom Line

Most individual investors will find public equity the practical way to own stocks, since it needs no accreditation, comes with audited disclosures and can be sold on any trading day. Private equity fits accredited investors and institutions that can lock up money for years, keep cash ready for capital calls and rely on a manager's reporting. Listed shares of asset managers offer indirect exposure, but they still behave like public stocks.