What Is the S&P 500? How the Index Works and Why It Matters

Search Fintrev

Search our guides, reviews and glossary.

The S&P 500 (Standard & Poor’s 500 Index) is a stock market index that tracks 500 leading publicly traded U.S. companies. Each company is weighted by its float-adjusted market capitalization. S&P Dow Jones Indices, a subsidiary of S&P Global, maintains the index. It covers roughly 80% of the total value of the U.S. equity market, so it is widely treated as the standard gauge of large U.S. stocks. When people say “the market was up today,” they usually mean the S&P 500, quoted under the ticker SPX.

The name says 500, but the index holds slightly more than 500 stocks. A few companies have two share classes listed, and both classes are included.

How the S&P 500 is weighted

The weighting formula

Each company’s share of the index equals its market cap divided by the combined market cap of all members:

Company weight = Company float-adjusted market cap ÷ Total float-adjusted market cap of the index

Market cap is the share price multiplied by the number of shares. The S&P 500 does not count every share a company has issued. It counts only the free float, meaning shares available for the public to trade. Shares held by insiders, founders, governments or other strategic holders that are unlikely to be sold are excluded. A company with a large insider stake therefore carries less weight than its headline market cap suggests.

Two consequences follow. First, weights change every trading day as prices move, with no action from the index provider. A stock that doubles while the rest of the index is flat roughly doubles its weight. Second, a company’s influence depends on its total float value, not on its share price. A $50 stock can outweigh a $500 stock if the cheaper company has many more shares outstanding.

Worked example: three-company index (hypothetical)

Consider a made-up index of three companies. All shares are assumed to be free float.

Now suppose Company A rises 10% and B and C are unchanged. A’s market cap grows by $20 billion, and the index’s total value goes from $400 billion to $420 billion. That is a 5% gain for the index. If Company C rose 10% instead, the index would gain only 2.5%.

For contrast, a price-weighted index of the same three stocks would simply add the share prices: $200 + $50 + $400 = $650. Company C, the smallest by market value, would have the most influence because it has the highest price (about 62% of the total). A 10% rise in Company A would lift a price-weighted index by about 3.1% ($20 ÷ $650). The Dow Jones Industrial Average works the price-weighted way, which is why the two indexes can move differently on the same day.

From market caps to the index level: the divisor

The S&P 500 is not quoted in trillions of dollars. Its level is the total float-adjusted market cap of its members divided by an index divisor:

Index level = Sum of float-adjusted market caps ÷ Divisor

S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes its methodology but does not release the divisor itself. The divisor’s job is to keep the index level continuous when the membership or share counts change for reasons other than market movement.

Hypothetical example: if the members are worth $400 billion and the divisor is 100 million, the index stands at 4,000. Now a company worth $40 billion is added. Without an adjustment, total value would jump to $440 billion and the index to 4,400, a 10% “gain” that no investor earned. So the divisor is raised to 110 million, and the level stays at 4,000. The same kind of adjustment is made for share issuance, buybacks, spin-offs and mergers. As a result, only price changes move the index level.

Price index vs. total return

The standard S&P 500 (SPX) is a price return index. When member companies pay cash dividends, the index level does not capture that income. S&P Dow Jones Indices also calculates a total return version that assumes dividends are reinvested. Over long periods, the gap between the two is substantial because dividends compound.

The distinction matters when you compare an index fund’s results with “the S&P 500.” A fund that collects and pays out dividends will look better than the price index and slightly worse than the total return index once fees and costs are deducted. Long-run return figures, such as S&P 500 average annual return and historical performance, should say which version they use.

How companies get into and out of the index

The S&P 500 is not simply the 500 largest U.S. companies by market value. Selection is made by S&P’s index committee, which applies published eligibility rules and also uses judgment to keep the index representative of the U.S. large-cap market and balanced across sectors.

To be eligible, a company generally must:

• Be based in the United States, judged on factors such as its domicile, headquarters and primary listing on a U.S. exchange.
• Meet a minimum market capitalization. The threshold is reviewed and raised periodically as markets grow.
• Be sufficiently liquid, with meaningful trading volume relative to its float-adjusted market value.
• Have a public float of at least 10% of its shares.
• Show positive earnings, measured as the sum of the trailing four quarters. The most recent quarter must also be positive.

Profitability is judged using reported earnings, the same figures behind earnings per share. The earnings screen is one reason a large company can sit outside the index: a company that has just gone public, or that is big but not yet profitable, may wait for years before joining.

The committee also controls removals. A company may leave the index when it is acquired, when it shrinks well below the size of its peers, or when it no longer fits the criteria. Because the committee looks at the whole picture, a member that slips below an entry threshold is not necessarily removed right away. This buffer limits needless turnover.

The index is rebalanced quarterly, in March, June, September and December. At these points float share counts and weights are updated, and scheduled membership changes take effect. Additions and deletions can also happen between rebalances when a corporate event such as a merger requires one.

Sector coverage and the S&P index family

The S&P 500 spans every major sector of the economy, including technology, financials, health care, consumer businesses, industrials and energy. Sector weights are not fixed. They follow the market value of the companies in each sector, so the index’s sector mix shifts as some industries grow faster than others.

The S&P 500 belongs to a larger set of S&P Dow Jones benchmarks:

• S&P MidCap 400: mid-sized U.S. companies.
• S&P SmallCap 600: smaller U.S. companies.
• S&P Composite 1500: the 500, 400 and 600 combined, covering about 90% of U.S. market capitalization.
• S&P Global 1200: a global index family in which the S&P 500 serves as the U.S. component.

There are also variants built from the same members, such as the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index and growth and value style indexes, in which a company is not counted in both growth and value at once.

How investors use the S&P 500

As a benchmark. Fund managers and individual investors measure performance against the S&P 500. A large-cap U.S. stock fund that trails it over long periods has a hard time justifying active management fees.

As an investable strategy. Index mutual funds and ETFs hold the member stocks in roughly the same weights as the index, so their returns track it closely before costs. The Vanguard 500 Index Fund and its ETF share class, VOO, are long-running examples. Many other fund companies offer similar products. Since the index is just a list and a calculation, the only way to “buy the S&P 500” is through one of these products or a derivative.

For trading and hedging. S&P 500 futures and options on the index (SPX options) let traders take positions on the whole market or hedge a stock portfolio without trading 500 stocks individually.

For valuation. Analysts calculate aggregate measures for the index, such as its price-to-earnings ratio, to judge whether U.S. large-cap stocks look cheap or expensive relative to history.

As an economic signal. Because its members earn revenue across the whole economy, the index is widely read as a sign of investor expectations for corporate profits and growth. It reflects stock prices, though, and those can move for reasons unrelated to current economic data.

S&P 500 vs. other benchmarks

S&P 500 vs. Dow Jones Industrial Average

The Dow Jones Industrial Average holds just 30 large U.S. companies and is price-weighted, as in the worked example above. The S&P 500 holds about 500 companies and is cap-weighted, so institutional investors generally treat it as the more representative benchmark. The Dow remains the older, more familiar headline number for many retail investors, and many large companies belong to both.

S&P 500 vs. Nasdaq indexes

Nasdaq is a stock exchange whose name also appears on several indexes. The Nasdaq Composite, often called simply “the Nasdaq,” includes more than 2,500 Nasdaq-listed stocks. The Nasdaq-100 holds 100 of the largest non-financial companies listed on the exchange. Membership depends on where a stock is listed, not on profitability or a selection committee, and a stock can belong to the S&P 500 and Nasdaq indexes at the same time. The Nasdaq indexes lean more heavily toward technology, so they often move further than the S&P 500 in both directions.

S&P 500 vs. Russell indexes

The Russell indexes, such as the Russell 1000 (large caps), Russell 2000 (small caps) and Russell 3000 (broad market), are also cap-weighted. They differ from the S&P family in two main ways. First, Russell membership is set by a rules-based ranking on market cap rather than by a committee with earnings requirements. Second, Russell style indexes can split a single company between growth and value, while S&P style indexes do not count a company in both.

S&P 500 vs. an S&P 500 index fund

The index is a calculation, and an index fund is a portfolio that owns shares to replicate it. A fund’s returns differ slightly from the index because of its expense ratio, trading costs, cash held for redemptions and the handling of dividends. This difference is called tracking difference. For a large, low-cost S&P 500 fund the gap is typically small, but it is never exactly zero.

Limitations of the S&P 500

Concentration. Cap weighting means a small group of the largest companies can account for a large share of the index’s value. When those stocks rise or fall sharply, they can drive the index’s result even if most members move the other way. Owning an S&P 500 fund is diversified across 500 names, but not evenly.

Momentum and overvaluation. A stock’s weight grows as its price rises, whether or not its profits justify the move. If a heavily weighted stock becomes overvalued, it inflates the index, and cap-weighted funds own more of it at higher prices. This is a key reason equal-weighted versions of the index have gained popularity: every member has the same influence, so the result reflects the typical stock rather than the biggest ones. An equal-weight S&P 500 fund rebalances regularly and usually charges a higher fee.

Large caps only. The index leaves out mid-sized and small companies, which the S&P MidCap 400, SmallCap 600 or Russell 2000 cover. It also excludes companies based outside the United States, even though many members earn a significant part of their revenue abroad.

Committee discretion. The rules are public, but committee judgment means index changes cannot always be predicted precisely from the criteria alone.

Why it’s called Standard & Poor’s

The index’s roots go back to 1923, when the Standard Statistics Company created a stock index covering 233 companies. In 1941 Standard Statistics merged with Poor’s Publishing, a financial publisher founded by Henry Varnum Poor, to form Standard & Poor’s. The modern 500-stock index was launched in 1957.

The Bottom Line

The S&P 500 matters to anyone who owns a U.S. stock index fund or measures a portfolio against large U.S. stocks. Investors can only buy it through funds, ETFs or derivatives, and those trail the index slightly after costs. Its 500 names offer diversification but not evenly, since a few large companies carry much of the weight, and mid-sized and small companies sit in other indexes.