Understanding Consumer Discretionary: Key Products and Economic Insights

Search Fintrev

Search our guides, reviews and glossary.

Consumer discretionary refers to goods and services that people want but do not need, bought only when income remains after essentials are covered. New cars, designer clothing, vacations, restaurant meals, furniture, big-screen televisions and streaming-free leisure such as theme parks all fall into this group. The term also names a stock market sector: the companies that make or sell these products, often called consumer discretionaries or consumer cyclicals.

What Consumer Discretionary Means

The word “discretionary” points to choice. A household has to buy toilet paper, groceries and gasoline; it has the discretion to decide whether to buy a new sofa this year or keep the old one.

The category is broad. It covers:

• Durable goods: automobiles, appliances, furniture, household electronics.
• Apparel and luxury items: high-end clothing, footwear, jewelry, handbags.
• Leisure and entertainment: hotels, cruises, casinos, gyms, sporting goods.
• Dining out: restaurant chains and coffee shops.
• Discretionary retail: department stores, home improvement chains, specialty retailers and online marketplaces.

The opposite group, non-discretionary or staple spending, covers items consumers treat as necessities regardless of conditions. The line between the two is not about price. A cheap fast-food meal is discretionary because it replaces a home-cooked one that costs less; an expensive prescription drug is non-discretionary because the buyer cannot easily go without it.

A related idea is discretionary income: the money left after taxes and necessary expenses such as housing, food and utilities. It differs from disposable income, which is income after taxes only. Discretionary spending is funded from discretionary income, so anything that shrinks that remainder (lower wages, job losses, higher prices for essentials, higher loan payments) hits discretionary companies first.

How Discretionary Demand Moves With the Economic Cycle

Economists describe the business cycle in four stages: expansion, peak, contraction and trough. From expansion to peak, businesses earn more, employment and wages tend to rise, and households feel less pressure to save for hard times. That combination raises spending on non-essentials. From contraction to trough, earnings weaken, households worry about income and they cut what they can cut, which is the discretionary portion of the budget.

The effect on discretionary demand is usually larger than the change in income itself, because essential spending is relatively fixed. A household that loses some income cannot reduce its rent or grocery bill by the same proportion, so the cut lands disproportionately on vacations, new cars and nights out.

Hypothetical example: why discretionary spending swings harder

Assume a household takes home $5,000 a month after taxes and spends $3,800 on essentials (rent, food, utilities, insurance, commuting). That leaves $1,200 for discretionary purchases.

Assumptions: essentials stay fixed and the household does not change its saving rate. Under those assumptions, a 10% change in income produces roughly a 42% change in the discretionary budget, in either direction. Across millions of households, that produces the pattern in discretionary company revenue: strong gains in good years and sharp drops in bad ones. Real households also adjust savings, borrowing and essentials, so actual swings differ.

The same logic applies to inflation. If the price of essentials rises faster than pay, the discretionary remainder shrinks even when nominal income is flat.

Economic Indicators That Track Discretionary Demand

Gross domestic product (GDP)

GDP is the broadest measure of economic output. Growing GDP signals an economy in which households and businesses are spending more; shrinking GDP signals contraction and more cautious spending. Consumer spending is itself a large component of U.S. GDP, so the two move together.

Consumer confidence

Confidence surveys ask households about their current and expected finances, business conditions and the job market, which helps forecast consumption and saving. When confidence falls, households tend to postpone vacations and delay purchases such as expensive clothing, new televisions and new cars. Weaker sales for the companies that make them can then feed back into job cuts and further contraction.

The best-known U.S. measure is the Consumer Confidence Index published by The Conference Board. The index is benchmarked so that 1985 equals 100. Readings above 100 indicate more optimism than in the benchmark year, which is associated with households saving less and planning major purchases over the following months. Readings below 100 point to a more pessimistic outlook, more saving and less spending. The University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment survey is another widely followed gauge of the same behavior.

Personal income and spending

The Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) publishes a monthly report on personal income and outlays. Its spending figure is known as personal consumption expenditures (PCE), and the report also includes the PCE Price Index, an inflation gauge closely followed by the Federal Reserve. The report breaks spending into durable goods, nondurable goods and services, which makes it useful for separating discretionary categories such as durables from more essential ones. In growth phases, income and spending both rise and purchases of non-essentials increase; in contractions, both tend to fall and discretionary purchases drop.

Interest rates and credit

Many discretionary purchases are financed. Cars are bought with auto loans, furniture and electronics are often put on credit cards or installment plans, and home-related spending tracks mortgage activity. When borrowing costs rise, monthly payments rise with them, which cuts into discretionary income and can make a big-ticket purchase unaffordable. Interest rates also matter on the company side, since retailers, automakers and hotel operators borrow to fund inventory, expansion and operations.

In general, rates tend to rise during growth phases and fall during contractions, and U.S. monetary policy typically seeks to lower rates in contractions to stimulate activity. For discretionary companies, falling rates can support a recovery in demand, while rapidly rising rates can slow it even when employment is still strong.

Other indicators

• Retail sales
• Nonfarm payrolls
• Unemployment rate
• Average hours worked
• Average hourly earnings
• Manufacturing activity surveys
• Services activity surveys
• Home sales
• Building and construction activity

Home sales and construction are especially relevant because a home purchase triggers spending on furniture, appliances and home improvement, all discretionary categories.

The Consumer Discretionary Sector and Its Industries

In equity markets, “consumer discretionary” is one of the sectors in the Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS), the framework used by S&P Dow Jones Indices and MSCI to sort companies. The sector has a manufacturing side (automobiles, household durables, textiles and apparel, leisure equipment) and a services side (hotels, restaurants and leisure, consumer services, and retailing).

Industries that have been part of the sector include:

• Auto components
• Automobiles
• Distributors
• Diversified consumer services (for example, education and personal services)
• Hotels, restaurants and leisure
• Household durables
• Internet and direct marketing retail
• Leisure products
• Multiline retail
• Specialty retail
• Textiles, apparel and luxury goods

GICS is revised periodically, and industry names and membership change. In 2018, for example, media and many internet companies were moved out of consumer discretionary into the newly created Communication Services sector. Retail categories have also been reorganized since, so a current index factsheet is the authority on exactly which industries and companies are included.

Companies commonly cited as consumer discretionary names include Amazon, Tesla, Home Depot, Nike, McDonald’s, Starbucks, Ford, Toyota, Hilton, Marriott, AutoZone, Macy’s, eBay, Tractor Supply, Domino’s Pizza, Thor Industries (recreational vehicles) and H&R Block (a consumer service). The mix shows how wide the sector is: a carmaker, a burger chain, a tax preparer and an online retailer sit in the same bucket because they all depend on consumer spending choices.

Because industry results react quickly to changes in discretionary income, analysts treat them as bellwethers. Auto sales, restaurant traffic and home improvement sales are often read as early signals of how households feel about their finances.

Consumer Discretionary vs. Consumer Staples

Consumer discretionary

• Sells products people can choose to buy or skip.
• Revenue and earnings tend to rise strongly in expansions.
• Stocks often lead the market higher when signs of growth or recovery appear.
• Stocks also tend to lead declines at the start of a contraction, as investors anticipate weaker spending.

Consumer staples

• Sells food, beverages, household and personal products, tobacco and similar necessities.
• Demand is relatively stable whatever the state of the economy.
• Stocks are often favored when the economy is contracting and can hold up comparatively well in recessions.
• Growth in strong economies is usually more modest, since people do not buy much more toothpaste when their pay rises.

Major staples companies include Procter & Gamble, PepsiCo, Coca-Cola, Costco and Philip Morris International. The sector ETF counterpart to XLY is the Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLP).

One more distinction causes confusion: consumer cyclical vs. consumer discretionary. These are largely two names for the same idea. Some data providers use “consumer cyclical” as their sector label, but their company lists do not always match GICS exactly.

How Investors Use the Sector

Sector ETFs and index funds. A sector fund spreads money across many discretionary companies, which limits single-company risk while keeping a concentrated bet on consumer spending. The Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLY), managed by State Street Global Advisors, holds the consumer discretionary stocks in the S&P 500. Mutual fund options include the Vanguard Consumer Discretionary Index Fund Admiral Shares.

Individual stocks. Buying single companies allows a more targeted view, such as favoring home improvement over restaurants or luxury over mass-market retail. The P/E ratio and earnings per share are common starting points. With cyclical companies, P/E needs care. Earnings peak near the top of the cycle, which can make a stock look cheap just before profits fall, and earnings collapse near the bottom, which can make it look expensive just before they recover.

Sector rotation. Some investors shift weight between discretionary and staples according to where they think the economy is in the cycle: more discretionary when indicators suggest recovery or expansion, more staples when they point to contraction. The approach depends on reading turning points correctly, and markets often move before the economic data confirms a shift.

Limitations of the Concept

Classification is by company, not by product. A company is placed in one sector based on its main business. Amazon is classified as consumer discretionary although a large part of its profit comes from cloud computing. Tesla’s share price is often driven by expectations about technology rather than by current car demand. A sector fund’s behavior can therefore reflect factors unrelated to household spending.

Concentration. Sector indexes such as the S&P 500 consumer discretionary group are weighted by market capitalization, so the largest companies carry the most weight. A few names can drive most of the sector’s return in a given period, and a sector ETF may be less diversified than its holding count suggests.

Not all discretionary businesses are equally cyclical. Discount retailers can gain customers who trade down in a downturn, while luxury brands serve buyers whose spending depends more on asset prices than on wages. Auto parts retailers can benefit when people repair old cars instead of buying new ones. Treating the whole sector as one cyclical trade misses these differences.

Indicators lag and get revised. GDP and PCE are reported after the fact and often revised. Confidence surveys measure feelings, which do not always translate into spending. Using indicators to time sector moves involves uncertainty at every step.

The Bottom Line

Investors weighing discretionary stocks against staples, and anyone tracking household spending, can treat the sector as a gauge of how much income remains after essentials. Its results swing harder than income across the business cycle, but sector funds are concentrated in a few large companies and not every business in them is equally cyclical. Indicators lag and get revised, so timing sector moves on economic data carries uncertainty.