What Is Communism? Ideology, History, and Impact

Search Fintrev

Search our guides, reviews and glossary.

Communism is a political and economic ideology that aims for a classless society in which property, and above all the means of production (land, factories, machinery and natural resources), is owned in common rather than by private individuals. Output is distributed according to need instead of through wages, prices and profit. In its full theoretical form, communism also has no state, no money and no social classes. Every country that has called itself communist has fallen far short of that description. These countries were usually one-party states that owned or controlled most of the economy and planned it from the center.

That gap between theory and practice explains most of the confusion: “communism” can mean Karl Marx’s idea of a future society, the political movement that tried to bring it about, or the regimes run by communist parties in the 20th and 21st centuries.

What Is Communism?

At its core, communism is a theory of who should own the things that produce wealth. In a capitalist system, private owners hold capital, hire labor and keep the profit. Communism rejects that arrangement. It argues that private ownership of capital divides society into those who own and those who must sell their labor to survive, and that this division is the root of inequality and conflict.

Communism opposes both capitalism and liberal democracy, replacing markets with collective decision-making and private property with common property. The label “communist” covers a wide range of ideologies, so it does not by itself say which version a person supports.

How Communism Works

Common ownership of the means of production

Economists group the inputs to production into the factors of production: land, labor, capital and entrepreneurship. Communism places land and capital under collective ownership. Labor remains with individuals, but in theory no one earns income simply by owning a factory or renting out land. Entrepreneurship as a private, profit-seeking activity largely disappears, because the community, not an individual, decides what to produce.

Personal possessions such as clothing or household goods are not the main target. The distinction communist theory draws is between personal property and private property that generates income from other people’s work.

From capitalism to socialism to communism

Marx and Engels predicted that a worldwide revolution by the working class would overthrow capitalism. They described the result as a two-step transition:

1. Socialism, a transitional stage in which the working class controls the state and the economy, and people are still rewarded roughly according to their work.
2. Communism, the final stage, in which class distinctions vanish, the state “withers away,” and goods are shared according to the principle “from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs.”

In this theory, communism marks the end of class struggle and therefore the end of history as Marx understood it. Marx and Engels also expected that religion and conventional family structures would fade along with property and classes.

Central planning in practice

No country has reached the stateless final stage. What communist governments actually built was a system of central planning run by a single ruling party. Instead of prices set by supply and demand, a planning agency set output targets (quotas), allocated raw materials and labor, and fixed prices. The Soviet Union organized this through Five-Year Plans covering agriculture, banking and industry.

A worked example (hypothetical)

Consider a hypothetical commune of 100 people that grows grain and makes tools. No one owns the fields or the workshop. A council meets each season and decides:

• Production: 70 people farm, 30 make tools, based on how much food and equipment the group expects to need.
• Distribution: grain goes to households by need. A family of six receives more than a single adult, whatever hours each person worked.
• No prices: tools are handed to whoever needs them rather than sold.

At this scale, the council can see everyone’s needs and output directly. Scale the same logic to a country of 150 million people and millions of distinct products, and the planner must estimate how many shoes, tractors, light bulbs and loaves of bread the country needs, in which sizes and places, and assign the steel, energy and workers to produce each. Every choice carries an opportunity cost: steel sent to tank factories cannot become refrigerators. Market economies settle these trade-offs through prices. A planned economy settles them through administrative decisions, and errors spread from one sector to the next.

Where the Idea Came From

The idea of shared property is much older than Marx. The Book of Acts in the Bible describes 1st-century Christian communities that held goods in common, a practice associated with the Greek term koinonia. In the 17th century, the English group known as the Diggers rejected private ownership of land on similar religious grounds.

The modern use of the word “communism” is traced to Victor d’Hupay, an 18th-century French aristocrat who promoted living in “communes” where all property would be shared so that everyone could benefit from everyone else’s work.

“The Communist Manifesto”

The defining text came in 1848, when Marx and Engels published “The Communist Manifesto.” It dropped the religious framing of earlier communal movements and offered what its authors presented as a materialist, scientific account of history. Its best-known line states that the history of all existing society is the history of class struggles.

In the Manifesto’s account, the French Revolution opened the capitalist era: the bourgeoisie, the merchant and owning class, took control of the means of production and overturned the feudal order. The conflict between nobles and serfs gave way to one between the bourgeoisie, who own capital, and the proletariat, who sell their labor for wages. Marx and Engels argued that the proletariat would eventually overthrow the bourgeoisie, and they presented this revolution as historically inevitable.

Communism in Practice

The Soviet Union

Marx and Engels died before any government tried to apply their ideas. In 1917, during World War I, revolution brought down the Russian czar. The Bolsheviks, a radical Marxist faction led by Vladimir Lenin, seized power and won the civil war that followed. They founded the Soviet Union in 1922 on the territory of the former Russian Empire.

Lenin had developed the theory of vanguardism: the idea that a small, disciplined elite party had to lead the working class toward socialism. After Lenin’s death in 1924, Joseph Stalin consolidated power and ruled until 1953 under the banner of the “dictatorship of the proletariat.” His rule brought forced agricultural collectivization and sweeping ethnic and political purges. Tens of millions died under Stalin, in addition to the enormous losses of the war with Nazi Germany.

The state did not wither away. It became a powerful one-party institution that banned dissent and controlled the main sectors of the economy. Central planning did deliver rapid industrialization, and Soviet growth in gross domestic product (GDP) outpaced that of the U.S. from 1950 to 1965. Over the longer run, however, the Soviet economy grew more slowly than its capitalist, democratic rivals. Planners favored heavy industry, which left consumer goods chronically in short supply.

In the 1980s, Mikhail Gorbachev introduced perestroika (economic restructuring that allowed more private enterprise) and glasnost (greater openness and freedom of expression). The reforms did not reverse the economic decline, and by loosening the state’s grip on dissent they may have hastened its end. The Soviet Union collapsed in 1991.

China

Mao Zedong’s Communist Party took control of China in 1949, after more than 20 years of war against the Nationalists and Imperial Japan. China became the second major Marxist-Leninist state. Mao initially allied with Moscow, but the Soviet Union’s de-Stalinization and its policy of “peaceful coexistence” with the West led to a split around 1958.

Mao’s rule resembled Stalin’s in its violence and its demand for ideological purity. During the Great Leap Forward (1958 to 1962), the party ordered the rural population to produce huge quantities of steel in an effort to industrialize quickly. The famine of that period killed at least 16 million people, and some estimates exceed 45 million. The Cultural Revolution, an ideological purge that ran from 1966 until Mao’s death in 1976, killed an estimated 1.6 million more and exposed millions to political persecution.

After Mao, Deng Xiaoping introduced market reforms, and later leaders continued them. Today the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) presides over a largely market-based economy in which state-owned enterprises still play a large role. Free expression is heavily restricted, and organized opposition to the party is not permitted.

The Cold War

The U.S. and the Soviet Union emerged from World War II as the two dominant powers and split Europe into rival blocs, divided by what Winston Churchill called the “Iron Curtain.” Once both had nuclear weapons, from 1949 onward, their rivalry became the Cold War. It came closest to direct conflict in the 1962 Cuban missile crisis. It was also fought indirectly, as in Vietnam, which was unified under communist rule in 1975 after the U.S. withdrew. The Cold War ended with the Soviet collapse in 1991.

Limitations of Communism

Weak incentives. In a market economy, the chance to earn profit drives competition and innovation. The ideal communist citizen was expected to work selflessly for society. When extra effort brings no extra reward, many workers and managers have little reason to produce more, improve quality or take risks.

The planning problem. Central planning requires gathering and processing enormous amounts of information about needs, resources and capacity, without prices that respond to supply and demand to signal what is scarce and what is wasted. Mistakes compounded across the economy, producing shortages in some goods and surpluses in others. Growth figures were sometimes inaccurate or falsified to match the plan, which hid problems from the planners themselves.

Concentrated power. Placing economic and political control in a few hands produced inefficiency and gave officials reasons to manipulate the system to keep their positions. Corruption became widespread, and surveillance, as in East Germany and the Soviet Union, was a standard feature of daily life.

Defenders of communist ideas often answer that the Soviet Union and Maoist China were authoritarian distortions that abandoned Marx’s goals. Critics reply that the repeated outcome across many countries shows that the model itself does not work at national scale. Small voluntary communes have sometimes functioned well, but they tend to stay small.

Communism vs. Socialism vs. Capitalism

• Communism calls for common ownership of all productive property, usually through revolution, and in theory a society without classes, a state or money.
• Socialism also favors public ownership and equality and seeks to empower the working class. It is the more moderate position: it generally allows a market sector to continue and prefers gradual, often democratic, change to revolution. Marx used it to describe the stage before communism, while many modern socialist parties work within democratic and market systems.
• Capitalism rests on private ownership of capital, markets that set prices, and profit as the reward for investment and risk.

A further distinction is worth keeping in mind. Communism is an economic and political ideology. Authoritarianism is a form of government. Communist states have been authoritarian, but the two words do not mean the same thing.

Types of Communism

“Communism” covers several schools of thought:

• Marxism, the original theory of class struggle and historical stages.
• Marxism-Leninism, which adds Lenin’s vanguard party and became the official doctrine of the Soviet Union.
• Maoism, Mao’s adaptation, which put peasants rather than industrial workers at the center of revolution.
• Trotskyism, associated with Leon Trotsky, which stressed worldwide revolution and opposed Stalin.
• Anarcho-communism, which seeks common ownership without any state at all, even during the transition.
• Religious or utopian communalism, the older tradition of shared property in faith-based communities.

Which Countries Are Communist Today?

Five countries are officially governed by communist parties: China, Cuba, Laos, North Korea and Vietnam. None matches Marx’s definition. All of them permit some private enterprise or market activity, China and Vietnam most extensively, and all are autocratic.

FAQs

The Bottom Line

Readers comparing economic systems should keep Marx's theory separate from the one-party states that used the name. No country has reached the stateless final stage, and national-scale planning repeatedly struggled with weak incentives, missing price signals and concentrated power. Defenders call those regimes distortions of Marx, while critics see a model that fails at national scale, and today's communist-led countries all rely partly on markets.